UGroups
Driver Usenet Groups Newsgroups

rude drivers nope. rude TRUCKERS... 1978

All right, I'll offer a serious reason why it wouldn't work. Cost. What you are proposing is very costly to build, very costly to maintain.

I seriously doubt that there will be developed a safe, reliable, and small enough nuclear power plant to operate at the single car level, or even at the single train level. Since you wanted to get away from fossil fuel, that leaves nuclear electric generation and distribution to the motors (engines, but electric engines are called motors). That much juice needs to travel by Catenary or third rail from the sub-station to the motor.

Electric powered trains perform much better, and last longer than their diesel-electric brethren. They out accelerate them hands down, their weight-hp ratio is much better, they don't have to carry their power source with them.

The big problem is the power distribution system. It is not trivial to build and maintain. And it's susceptible to things like weather knocking down lines, flooding third rails, etc. All these make to an expensive system. You'll notice that in the USA, electrified tracks are concentrated in high population density areas where these high costs can be spread out over a larger population.

Rail does have it's part to the solution. As capacity grows, so will the amount of fright that gets transported, probably via containerizes freight.

Dream Transportations System. Was:rude drivers nope. rude TRUCKERS... 1981
I wanted to revisit this, as it is the most common comeback to anyone that tries to suggest doing...

Pbuttenger rail can compete with airlines where total door to door travel times are close, but cross-country pbuttenger rail at this time is in trouble. It will take separate rights of way and very high speeds.

Dream Transportations System. Was:rude drivers nope. rude TRUCKERS
And see what that did to the rail network. You know, it's amazing the power of NIMBYs. If you look at I95 through Philadelphia, it's mostly elevated. Except past Society...

Don't get me wrong I love trains, and I want to see a greater share of the transportation problem go to them. But there are some very serious obstacles to overcome.

rude drivers nope. rude TRUCKERS... 1979
So was the interstate highway system (costly), but we built it. OK, I don't see how you missed this fact so far, but this would run on fixed plant nuclear...

Doug




List | Previous | Next
rude drivers nope. rude TRUCKERS... 1979 | rude drivers nope. rude TRUCKERS... 1977